Rafe's tells Alison he feels something's wrong at Stephen's party. After sharing a passionate kiss, Ian deflects Lucy's questions about their relationship. Seeing the identical cuts on Tess and Livvie's hands, Jack calls Ian, but Livvie takes off. Suspecting Rafe sent Tess to drive her crazy, Livvie goes to the party to confront him. Stephen intercepts her and they dance. Staring into his eyes, she remembers Caleb. Rafe sees them dancing and also looks at Stephen's eyes. He rips off his mask but discovers Joshua. Stephen seduces a drunk Elizabeth at a bar. Two masked men attempt to mug Lucy, then stab Ian.